The meeting focused on the pre-submission Portsmouth local plan, with significant discussions on housing targets, environmental concerns, and infrastructure needs. Several deputations from the public opposed the plan, citing issues like climate change, air pollution, and the impact on natural habitats.

Pre-submission Portsmouth Local Plan

The main topic was the pre-submission Portsmouth local plan, which aims to guide the city's development over the next 15 years. The plan proposes building 13,603 new homes, which some members of the public and councillors believe is too high. Concerns were raised about the environmental impact, including increased air pollution, loss of natural habitats, and the risk of flooding.

Public Deputations

1. Viola Langley opposed the plan, arguing that the number of homes proposed is too high and would exacerbate environmental issues like air pollution and loss of biodiversity.
2. Rod Bailey also opposed the plan, questioning the evidence supporting the housing target of 14,400 homes and highlighting the city's existing congestion and air pollution problems.
3. Paula Savage raised concerns about air pollution, particularly from the port, and questioned the effectiveness of mitigation plans.
4. David Langley pointed out the contradiction in the plan, which acknowledges climate change risks but still proposes significant development that could increase flood risks.

Councillor Discussions

1. Councillor Mason highlighted the challenges in achieving a consensus on housing targets, affordable homes, and the development of areas like Tippner West and Horsey Island East. He emphasized the need for a balanced approach to development.
2. Councillor Simpson expressed concerns about the HMO (Houses in Multiple Occupation) policy, arguing that the 10% threshold within a 50-meter radius is too high and does not reflect the unique needs of Portsmouth.
3. Councillor Hunt stressed the importance of the plan for addressing housing needs and sea defences, particularly in areas like Tippner and North End.
4. Councillor Sanders discussed the balance between protecting the environment and meeting housing needs, emphasizing the importance of providing affordable housing.
5. Councillor Pitt thanked the planning team for their hard work and highlighted the importance of having a valid local plan to guide development and avoid falling back on the national planning policy framework.

Amendment and Vote

An amendment proposed by Councillor Bosher and seconded by Councillor Swan was accepted, ensuring that opposition spokespersons are included in consultations on minor changes to the plan. The council voted to approve the pre-submission Portsmouth local plan, with 31 votes in favor, 1 against, and 7 abstentions.

Conclusion

The council resolved to approve the draft pre-submission Portsmouth local plan for public consultation, subject to minor changes agreed upon by the Assistant Director of Planning and Economic Growth in consultation with the portfolio holder and opposition spokespersons. The final local plan will be brought back to the council for formal adoption following an independent examination.