Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Sutton Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

Council - Monday, 29th January, 2024 7.00 pm

January 29, 2024 at 7:00 pm Council View on council website Watch video of meeting Read transcript (Professional subscription required)

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“What specific budget items will be discussed?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

Open Council Network is an independent organisation. We report on Sutton and are not the council. About us

The Council meeting on 29 January 2024 addressed significant concerns regarding the cost of social care, the implementation of 20mph speed limits, and housing legislation. Key decisions included urging the government to properly fund social care, rejecting blanket 20mph speed limits on main roads, and agreeing to an updated procedure for handling standards complaints against councillors.

Cost of Care

Council noted the increasing financial pressures on local authorities due to soaring social care costs, with a significant shortfall in funding across London. Councillor Marian James, Chair of the People Committee, moved a motion highlighting that central government funding had reduced by 60% since 2011, placing a greater burden on council tax. The motion also acknowledged the broken promise by Boris Johnson to fix the social care crisis and the increasing costs of care packages for both adults and children. Councillor Mike Dwyer moved an amendment that was subsequently lost, and the original motion was carried.

The Council resolved to:

  • Urge the government to properly fund social care through national taxation rather than council tax.
  • Insist the government provides additional funding for children's services to reduce demand and enhance outcomes.
  • Partner with other London boroughs to develop specialised children's homes and lobby for new investment in adult social care.
  • Call on the government to reform carers' allowance and reject proposals to restrict visa rules for health and care workers.

20mph Speed Limits

Councillor Neil Garratt moved a motion to reject blanket 20mph speed limits on main roads, arguing that such a policy would increase congestion and travel times, disproportionately affecting outer London boroughs like Sutton. Councillor Barry Lewis, Leader of the Council, moved an amendment that was carried, which proposed continuing to consider 20mph speed limits on a case-by-case basis where there is local support and a clear safety benefit. The amended motion was subsequently carried.

The Council resolved to:

  • Reject the principle of blanket 20mph speed limits across the borough, including main roads, and commit to considering each road individually.
  • Continue to consider roads where a 20mph speed limit is appropriate, working with residents and ward members.
  • Hold a summit with various stakeholders, including the Mayor of London, to discuss 20mph limits and road safety in the borough.

Implementing Housing Legislation

Councillor Sheila Berry moved a motion concerning the implementation of housing legislation, particularly focusing on damp and mould in social housing. An amendment moved by Councillor Ed Parsley and seconded by Councillor Jake Short, and a further amendment moved by Councillor Wendy Clark and seconded by Councillor David Hicks, were both carried. The substantive motion, as amended, was then carried.

The Council resolved to:

  • Affirm the value of social housing and acknowledge the need for government support for national social housing build and retrofit programmes.
  • Highlight Sutton's efforts in providing new social housing and retrofit programmes, such as EnergieSprong.
  • Welcome the Social Housing Regulation Act 2023 and the proposed extension of Awaab's Law to the private rented sector.
  • Pledge to work with local social landlords to address damp and mould issues promptly.
  • Note the lack of central government provision for temporary accommodation charges.
  • Commit to working with developers to prioritise families in substandard conditions and to investigate infill sites for affordable housing.
  • Respond to the government consultation on housing legislation.

Constitutional Update

Councillor Ruth Dombey, Chair of the Strategy and Resources Committee, moved a resolution to update the Standards Regime Complaints Procedure. This was agreed by Council.

Requisition Regarding Beech Tree Place

Councillor Ed Parsley, Vice Chair of the Housing, Economy and Business Committee, moved a resolution concerning the Beech Tree Place regeneration project. The resolution to appoint Bidder A via direct award from the Construction London (Above £10m) Framework to complete the construction was carried.

Cost of Care Motion

Councillor Marian James moved a motion concerning the cost of social care, highlighting the significant funding shortfall and the impact on services. An amendment by Councillor Mike Dwyer was lost, and the original motion was carried. The Council resolved to urge the government to properly fund social care, provide additional funding for children's services, partner with other London boroughs on housing and adult social care, reform carers' allowance, and reject proposals to restrict visa rules for health and care workers.

20mph Speed Limits Motion

Councillor Neil Garratt's motion regarding 20mph speed limits was amended by Councillor Barry Lewis. The amended motion, which rejected blanket 20mph limits on main roads and committed to considering individual roads, was carried.

Implementing Housing Legislation

Councillor Sheila Berry's motion on implementing housing legislation saw two amendments, one by Councillor Ed Parsley and another by Councillor Wendy Clark. Both amendments were carried, and the substantive motion as amended was also carried. The Council pledged to work with social landlords to address damp and mould, welcomed new legislation, and committed to responding to government consultations on housing.

Constitutional Update

Councillor Ruth Dombey moved a resolution to update the Standards Regime Complaints Procedure, which was agreed.

Requisition Regarding Beech Tree Place

Councillor Ed Parsley moved a resolution to appoint Bidder A to complete the construction of the Beech Tree Place regeneration project, which was carried.

Questions from Councillors

A total of 33 questions were asked by councillors, covering a range of topics including police abstractions, the London Cancer Hub, social care funding, parking reviews, and housing development. Responses were provided by relevant lead members.

Questions from Members of the Public

Three questions were asked by members of the public, covering topics such as support for community organisations seeking venues, reassurances on youth safety, and the council's response to crime.

The meeting concluded at 10:34 pm. The next council meeting is scheduled for 4 March 2024, which will focus on the budget.

Attendees

Profile image for Councillor Steve Alvarez
Councillor Steve Alvarez Local Conservatives • St Helier West
Profile image for Councillor Isabel Araujo
Councillor Isabel Araujo Vice Chair: Environment and Sustainable Transport Committee; Vice Chair: Carshalton and Clockhouse Local Committee • Liberal Democrat • Carshalton Central
Profile image for Councillor Rob Beck
Councillor Rob Beck Vice Chair: People Committee • Liberal Democrat • Stonecot
Profile image for Councillor Moira Butt
Councillor Moira Butt Local Conservatives • Carshalton South and Clockhouse
Profile image for Councillor Andrew Jenner
Councillor Andrew Jenner Chair: Carshalton and Clockhouse Local Committee • Liberal Democrat • Carshalton Central
Profile image for Councillor Patrick Magnus
Councillor Patrick Magnus Local Conservatives • South Beddington and Roundshaw
Profile image for Councillor Wendy Clark
Councillor Wendy Clark Local Conservatives • St Helier West
Profile image for Councillor Richard Clifton
Councillor Richard Clifton Vice Chair: Planning Committee • Liberal Democrat • Sutton South
Profile image for Councillor Paul Cole
Councillor Paul Cole Vice Chair: People Committee • Liberal Democrat • St Helier East
Profile image for Councillor Bobby Dean
Councillor Bobby Dean Liberal Democrat • The Wrythe
Profile image for Councillor Ruth Dombey
Councillor Ruth Dombey Vice Chair: Sutton Local Committee • Liberal Democrat • Sutton North
Profile image for Councillor Peter Geiringer
Councillor Peter Geiringer Local Conservatives • Worcester Park South
Profile image for Councillor Barry Lewis
Councillor Barry Lewis Leader of the Council • Liberal Democrat • Wallington North
Profile image for Councillor Cryss Mennaceur
Councillor Cryss Mennaceur Chair: Pension Committee • Liberal Democrat • Sutton Central
Profile image for Councillor Patrick Ogbonna
Councillor Patrick Ogbonna Chair: Hackbridge, St Helier and the Wrythe Local Committee • Liberal Democrat • The Wrythe
Profile image for Councillor Ed Parsley
Councillor Ed Parsley Vice Chair: Housing, Economy and Business Committee • Liberal Democrat • Sutton Central
Profile image for Councillor Joe Quick
Councillor Joe Quick Local Conservatives • Worcester Park North
Profile image for Councillor Christopher Woolmer
Councillor Christopher Woolmer Chair: Environment and Sustainable Transport Committee • Liberal Democrat • Sutton West and East Cheam
Profile image for Councillor Sam Cumber
Councillor Sam Cumber Chair: Sutton Local Committee • Liberal Democrat • Sutton North
Profile image for Councillor Tom Drummond
Councillor Tom Drummond Leader of the Opposition • Local Conservatives • Worcester Park North
Profile image for Councillor Tim Foster
Councillor Tim Foster Leader of the Sutton Independent Residents Group • Sutton Independent Residents • Beddington
Profile image for Councillor David Hicks
Councillor David Hicks Local Conservatives • Belmont
Profile image for Councillor James McDermott-Hill
Councillor James McDermott-Hill Deputy Leader of the Opposition • Local Conservatives • North Cheam
Profile image for Councillor Jane Pascoe
Councillor Jane Pascoe Vice Chair: Sutton South, Cheam and Belmont Local Committee • Local Conservatives • Belmont
Profile image for Councillor Cumar Sahathevan
Councillor Cumar Sahathevan Deputy Mayor, Vice Chair: Licensing Committee • Liberal Democrat • Stonecot
Profile image for Councillor Sheldon Vestey
Councillor Sheldon Vestey Labour • Hackbridge
Profile image for Eric Allen
Eric Allen Local Conservatives • Cheam
Profile image for Councillor Martina Allen
Councillor Martina Allen Chair: Cheam North and Worcester Park Local Committee • Local Conservatives • Worcester Park South
Profile image for Councillor Tim Crowley
Councillor Tim Crowley Local Conservatives • Carshalton South and Clockhouse
Profile image for Councillor Mike Dwyer
Councillor Mike Dwyer Local Conservatives • North Cheam
Profile image for Councillor Qasim Esak
Councillor Qasim Esak Vice Chair: Scrutiny Committee • Liberal Democrat • Sutton West and East Cheam
Profile image for Councillor Trish Fivey
Councillor Trish Fivey Chair: Licensing Committee • Liberal Democrat • Sutton South
Profile image for Councillor Nick Mattey
Councillor Nick Mattey Sutton Independent Residents • Beddington
Profile image for Councillor Jayne McCoy
Councillor Jayne McCoy Chair: Planning Committee • Liberal Democrat • Wallington South
Profile image for Councillor Gemma Munday
Councillor Gemma Munday Liberal Democrat • St Helier East
Profile image for Councillor Muhammad Sadiq
Councillor Muhammad Sadiq Chair: Beddington and Wallington Local Committee • Liberal Democrat • Wallington South
Profile image for Councillor Colin Stears
Councillor Colin Stears Chair, Audit and Governance Committee; Vice Chair, Hackbridge, St Helier and the Wrythe Local Committee • Liberal Democrat • The Wrythe
Profile image for Councillor Luke Taylor
Councillor Luke Taylor Liberal Democrat • Sutton West and East Cheam
Profile image for Councillor Jillian Green
Councillor Jillian Green Sutton Independent Residents • Beddington
Profile image for Councillor Amy Haldane
Councillor Amy Haldane  Liberal Democrat •  Carshalton South and Clockhouse
Profile image for Councillor Bryony Lindsay-Charlton
Councillor Bryony Lindsay-Charlton Local Conservatives • Sutton North
Profile image for Param Nandha
Param Nandha Vice Chair: North Cheam, Stonecot and Worcester Park Local Committee • Local Conservatives • North Cheam
Profile image for Councillor Jonathan Pearce
Councillor Jonathan Pearce Local Conservatives • South Beddington and Roundshaw
Profile image for Councillor Dave Tchil
Councillor Dave Tchil Leader of the Labour Group • Labour • Hackbridge
Profile image for Councillor Vanessa Udall
Councillor Vanessa Udall Local Conservatives • Cheam
Profile image for Councillor Neil Garratt
Councillor Neil Garratt Local Conservatives • Belmont
Profile image for Councillor Sunita Gordon
Councillor Sunita Gordon Lead Member for Resources • Liberal Democrat • Wallington North
Profile image for Councillor Marian James
Councillor Marian James Chair: People Committee • Liberal Democrat • Wallington North
Profile image for Councillor Edward Joyce
Councillor Edward Joyce Chair: Scrutiny Committee, Vice Chair: Beddington and Wallington Local Committee • Liberal Democrat • South Beddington and Roundshaw
Profile image for Councillor Sam Martin
Councillor Sam Martin Deputy Leader of the Council • Liberal Democrat • Wallington South
Profile image for Councillor Louise Phelan
Councillor Louise Phelan Mayor • Liberal Democrat • Sutton South
Profile image for Councillor Tony Shields
Councillor Tony Shields Chair: Sutton South, Cheam and Belmont Local Committee • Local Conservatives • Cheam
Profile image for Councillor Jake Short
Councillor Jake Short Chair: Housing, Economy and Business Committee • Liberal Democrat • Carshalton Central

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council.pdf
20240129 Council questions 8.6 - questions only agenda.pdf
20240129 Council questions 8.7 - questions only agenda 1.pdf
Agenda frontsheet 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council
20240129 Council questions 8.7 - questions only agenda 1
20240129 Council questions 8.6 - questions only agenda
Appendix A Minutes HEB 17 January 2024 agenda item 8

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council.pdf

Minutes

Public minutes 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council.pdf

Additional Documents

Supplement Questions to Council 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council.pdf
Requisition 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council.pdf
Amendments 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council.pdf
20240304 Appendix A Council questions 8.6_ 29 January 2024.pdf
20240304 Appendix B Council questions 8.7 _ 29 January 2024.pdf
Amendment_ The Cost of Care.pdf
Requisition of Award of the contract for the completion of construction of the Beech Tree Place Rege.pdf
Supplement Questions to Council 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council
Public minutes 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council
Minutes Public Pack 30102023 Council
20240304 Appendix A Council questions 8.6_ 29 January 2024
Requisition 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council
20240304 Appendix B Council questions 8.7 _ 29 January 2024
Amendments 29th-Jan-2024 19.00 Council
Motion_ The Cost of Care _ Council _ 20240129
Motion_ 20mph Speed Limits _ Council _ 20240129 1
Amendment_ 20mph speed limits
Amendment_ The Cost of Care
Motion_ Implementing Housing Legislation _ Council _ 20240129
Amendment 1 to Motion_ Implementing Housing Legislation _ Council _ 20240129
Amendment 2 to Motion_ Implementing Housing Legislation _ Council _ 20240129
Constitutional Update - Report 11122023 Strategy and Resources Committee
Constitutional Update - Appendix A 11122023 Strategy and Resources Committee
Requisition of Award of the contract for the completion of construction of the Beech Tree Place Rege
8 20240117 _ R_ Award of the contract for the completion of construction of the Beech Tree Place R
8c BTP Climate Impact Assessment 17012024 Housing Economy and Business Committee
Draft Minute Strategy and Resources Committee _ Council _ 20240129
Minutes Public Pack 30102023 Council.pdf
Motion_ The Cost of Care _ Council _ 20240129.pdf
Motion_ 20mph Speed Limits _ Council _ 20240129 1.pdf
Amendment_ 20mph speed limits.pdf
Motion_ Implementing Housing Legislation _ Council _ 20240129.pdf
Amendment 1 to Motion_ Implementing Housing Legislation _ Council _ 20240129.pdf
Amendment 2 to Motion_ Implementing Housing Legislation _ Council _ 20240129.pdf
Draft Minute Strategy and Resources Committee _ Council _ 20240129.pdf
Constitutional Update - Report 11122023 Strategy and Resources Committee.pdf
Constitutional Update - Appendix A 11122023 Strategy and Resources Committee.pdf
Appendix A Minutes HEB 17 January 2024 agenda item 8.pdf
8c BTP Climate Impact Assessment 17012024 Housing Economy and Business Committee.pdf
8 20240117 _ R_ Award of the contract for the completion of construction of the Beech Tree Place R.pdf