Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Sutton Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

Pension Committee - Tuesday, 7th October, 2025 7.00 pm

October 7, 2025 View on council website

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Why was McCloud Remedy's deadline missed?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

Councillor Cryss Mennaceur, Chair of the Pension Committee, led a meeting where members reviewed the fund's performance, administration, and future strategies. The committee approved a draft Funding Strategy Statement and delegated authority for key actions regarding investment management and advisor appointments. They also noted updates on administration performance, projects, governance, and investment performance.

Triennial Valuation and Funding Strategy Statement

The committee approved the draft Funding Strategy Statement (FSS) for the pension fund1, a document required by LGPS 2 regulations that sets out the fund's approach to meeting its long-term pension liabilities. The FSS connects the actuarial valuation to the practical funding policies of the fund, especially how contribution rates are set and reviewed for all scheme employers. The main changes to the FSS included structural alignment, standardised terminology, enhanced governance, and updated assumptions.

The committee also noted the initial whole fund results, the proposed valuation assumptions, and the potential impact of market volatility after 31 March. The triennial valuation, which occurs every three years, assesses the pension scheme's assets and liabilities using market conditions to calculate the overall funding position.

Key assumptions for the valuation include:

  • A prudence level of at least 85%, resulting in a future investment return assumption (discount rate) of at least 5.3% per annum (pa).
  • A CPI inflation assumption of 2.3% pa, based on best estimate inflation projections from the Actuary's model.
  • Longevity assumptions set in line with the Fund Actuary's best estimate assumptions, supported by Club Vita analysis.

Pension Administration Performance Update

The committee noted an update on the key administration performance of the Shared Pensions Administration Service. The report highlighted a significant reduction in outstanding processes, falling from 962 to 820 since the last report, with no outstanding cases overdue by more than three months.

To maintain performance, officers developed two new Key Performance Indicators (KPIs):

  • No more than 10% of all cases will be overdue.
  • No more than 10% of overdue cases will be more than a month overdue.

A backlog threshold was set for each target, with a recovery plan to be implemented if performance reaches the backlog threshold.

Pension Administration Projects Update

The committee approved the Pensions Dashboard Matching Policy and noted updates on key administration projects.

Annual Benefit Statements: The production of the 2025 statements was complete, with 100% of deferred member statements and 89.09% of active member statements produced and published to the member portal. The remaining active member statements relate to members with unprocessed leaver processes, which require individual resolution.

Pensions Dashboard: The fund's implementation project is on track to meet the statutory staging date of 31 October 2025. The committee approved a formal Data Matching Policy, which defines the data items and criteria the fund will use to verify a member's identity and match them to their correct pension record. The policy is based on two types of match:

  • Full Match: Achieved when three core data items are successfully verified: surname, date of birth, and National Insurance number.
  • Partial Match: Occurs when there is a high probability of a match, but one piece of data may be inconsistent.

McCloud Remedy: The fund did not meet the statutory implementation deadline of 31 August 2025, due to delays in receiving a functional software solution and challenges relating to historic data collection. A revised project plan has been established with a new target completion date of 30 June 2026, and the breach has been reported to the Pensions Regulator3 (tPR).

Annual Report and Accounts 2024-2025

The committee was asked to approve the Pension Fund Annual Report 2024/25 and delegate to the Strategic Director of Resources any changes required as a result of the external audit.

Key points from the report included:

  • The Fund's net assets rose from £924m to £979m during 2024/25, an increase of £55m.
  • The Fund returned 3.7% over the year, ahead of the Pensions & Investment Research Consultants (PIRC) local authority universe average.
  • Total contributions received in 2024/25 were £73.747m, significantly higher than £49.086m in 2023/24, largely due to transfers into the Fund.
  • The Fund increased its proportion of assets pooled with the London CIV4 (LCIV) to 84% at the end of March 2025.

Governance and Risk Update

The committee noted an update on key governance activities and reviewed the fund's risk register. The risk register categorises all risks under three main themes: administration, funding and investments, and governance. As of the report, administration risks were rated amber overall, with one red and two amber risks. Funding and investments and governance risks were rated green.

The red rated risk was the failure of software provider Civica to provide software compliant with LGPS Regulations.

Work Programme Update

The committee noted the updated Work Programme, which sets out the proposed indicative agenda items for the committee meetings that are due to take place over the next year.

Quarterly Investment and Manager Performance

The committee noted the performance of the fund during the quarter ended 30 June 2025, the fund's actual asset allocation, funding level, and cashflow position as at 30 June 2025, and the update on the LCIV.

Key points from the report included:

  • The market value of the fund's assets at 30 June 2025 was £1,018m, an increase of £52m over the previous quarter.
  • The fund outperformed the benchmark by 0.8% over the quarter, with a return of 3.9% against a benchmark of 3.1%.
  • The funding level as at 30 June 2025 was 150%, compared to 101% at the previous triennial valuation of 31 March 2022.

The committee delegated authority to the Section 151 Officer for signing an Investment Management Agreement (IMA) with the LCIV and to carry out an open procurement exercise for an independent advisor for the fund and to make the appointment decision.


  1. A funding strategy statement (FSS) is a document that sets out how a pension fund will meet its long-term liabilities. It includes information on contribution rates, investment strategies, and risk management. 

  2. The Local Government Pension Scheme (LGPS) is a statutory pension scheme for local government workers in the United Kingdom. 

  3. The Pensions Regulator (TPR) is the UK regulator of work-based pension schemes. 

  4. The London Collective Investment Vehicle (LCIV) is an asset pool for London local authority pension funds. 

Attendees

Profile image for CouncillorCryss Mennaceur
Councillor Cryss Mennaceur  Chair: Pension Committee •  Liberal Democrat •  Sutton Central
Profile image for CouncillorSam Martin
Councillor Sam Martin  Deputy Leader of the Council •  Liberal Democrat •  Wallington South
Profile image for CouncillorRichard Choi
Councillor Richard Choi  Liberal Democrat •  Sutton Central
Profile image for CouncillorPaul Cole
Councillor Paul Cole  Vice Chair: People Committee •  Liberal Democrat •  St Helier East
Profile image for CouncillorJake Short
Councillor Jake Short  Chair: Housing, Economy and Business Committee •  Liberal Democrat •  Carshalton Central
Profile image for CouncillorTom Drummond
Councillor Tom Drummond  Leader of the Opposition •  Local Conservatives •  Worcester Park North
Profile image for CouncillorPatrick Magnus
Councillor Patrick Magnus  Local Conservatives •  South Beddington and Roundshaw

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 07th-Oct-2025 19.00 Pension Committee.pdf

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 07th-Oct-2025 19.00 Pension Committee.pdf

Minutes

Minutes Public Pack 24062025 Pension Committee.pdf

Additional Documents

Declarations of interest.pdf
Fire Precautions - Civic Offices.pdf
Triennial Valuation and Funding Strategy Statement Update.pdf
Appendix A - Triennial Valuation and Funding Strategy Statement Update.pdf
Appendix A - Benefits processing performance data.pdf
Appendix B - Triennial Valuation and Funding Strategy Statement Update.pdf
Pension Administration Performance Update.pdf
Pension Administration Projects Update.pdf
Appendix A - Pension Dashboard Programme - Implementation Plan.pdf
Appendix B - Pension Dashboard Programme - Data Matching Policy.pdf
Appendix C - McCloud Remedy Project Plan.pdf
Annual Report and Accounts 2024-25.pdf
Appendix A - DRAFT LBS Pension Fund Annual Report 2024-25.pdf
Risk Register Overview Report.pdf
Appendix A - Risk Register Overview Report - Pension Committee.pdf
Work Programme Update.pdf
Quarterly Investment and Manager Performance to 30 June 2025.pdf
Appendix A - London Borough of Sutton Pension Fund Q2 2025.pdf