Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Surrey Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

Council - Tuesday, 10 December 2024 10.00 am

December 10, 2024 View on council website Watch video of meeting Read transcript (Professional subscription required)

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Why close Bagshot recycling centre despite fly-tipping concerns?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

The Council voted to approve the scheme for admitting students to schools in 2026. It also agreed to close the Bagshot Community Recycling Centre, and to extend the opening hours of the Camberley Community Recycling Centre. It voted to adopt the reports from the Cabinet meetings that took place on 29 October and 26 November 2024, approved a motion on climate change and net zero targets, and referred motions on inheritance tax, farming and the rural economy, and the preventative approach to children's services to the Cabinet. A motion to allow parents to attend SEND panels was also referred to the Cabinet.

Climate Change

Councillor Catherine Baart proposed a motion noting the UK's commitment to reducing its carbon emissions to net zero by 2050 and by 68% from 1990 levels by 2030, and calling for a report that identifies the resources needed to enable the Council to achieve net zero in line with the UK's legal commitment. Councillor Baart explained that

we are just on target for our 2030 and 2050 net zero goals, which is, of course, positive, and it's the result of hard work by officers and councillors. But we have now finished the straightforward wins, like putting LEDs in streetlights.

Councillor Marissa Heath said that she had no issues supporting the motion, and explained that work on the report had already started. She said

we have made a decision recognising the difficult place we're in with the net zero targets that we're going to bring forward our plan. So it was due in 2026. We're bringing it forward now to completely review it, to consider where our risk spots are, what we need in order to meet those targets.

The motion was carried.

Inheritance Tax, Farming, and the Rural Economy

Councillor Marissa Heath proposed a motion to inform the Treasury that the Council disagrees with proposals to reduce the Inheritance Tax (IHT) threshold to £1.3 million, and called for it to be scrapped. Councillor Heath explained that:

The recent budget has had an immediate impact on farmers and rural businesses at a time when stability is important and as we seek to provide more healthy, sustainable and, where possible, local, food and look after our environment.

Councillor Fellows proposed an amendment to the motion that called for a review of the IHT policy and changes to the National Planning Policy Framework to reduce tax avoidance through land banking. He explained that

Whatever the views on Brexit, leaving the common agricultural policy, leaving the single market, has made life harder and more complex for farmers.

Councillor Michelle Martin argued against the amendment, saying

Majority of farms live on an overdraft. How on earth are they going to save to pay for the inheritance tax?

The amendment was lost, and the motion was carried.

SEND Panels

Councillor Liz Townsend proposed a motion calling on the Cabinet to allow parents and children to be present at SEND panels, and for the family's case worker to automatically be invited to attend. Councillor Townsend argued that

Parents are their child's best advocates. They understand their children better than anyone. Having parents and children present ensures their voices are heard directly, providing crucial first-hand insight into their child's strengths, their challenges, and their aspirations.

Councillor Curran said that she recognised Councillor Townsend's concerns, but explained that

SEND services and operational arrangements must be conducted in accordance with the regulatory requirements of the Children and Families Act and the SEND Code of Practice, both of which are hugely prescriptive, and I doubt whether any of us here in this Chamber have the specialist and wide knowledge of that area of legislation.

The Council voted to refer the motion to the Cabinet.

Preventative Approach to Children's Services

Councillor Jonathan Essex proposed a motion to review research on the benefits of a preventative approach to children's services, and to call for funding from central government. He explained that

Budget constraints have led to our children's services work being targeted close to statue services, effective in reducing children being brought into care, but also reducing prevention and emerging need support to a wider set of families.

The motion was referred to the Children, Families, Lifelong Learning Select Committee.

Bagshot Community Recycling Centre

The Council voted to approve the Cabinet's recommendation to close the Bagshot Community Recycling Centre and extend the opening hours of the Camberley Community Recycling Centre. The Cabinet noted that the Bagshot site is small, unmodernised, and not fit for purpose, and that there was a pattern of vandalism, fly-tipping, and unlawful entry at the site.

Attendees

Profile image for Ayesha Azad
Ayesha Azad Conservative
Profile image for Catherine Baart
Catherine Baart The Green Party
Profile image for Steve Bax
Steve Bax Deputy Cabinet Member for Highways • Conservative
Profile image for John Beckett
John Beckett Residents Association
Profile image for Jordan Beech
Jordan Beech Conservative
Profile image for Luke Bennett
Luke Bennett Conservative
Profile image for Amanda Boote
Amanda Boote Independent
Profile image for Dennis Booth
Dennis Booth Residents for Guildford and Villages
Profile image for Harry Boparai
Harry Boparai Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Liz Bowes
Liz Bowes Conservative
Profile image for Natalie Bramhall
Natalie Bramhall Cabinet Member for Property, Waste and Infrastructure • Conservative
Profile image for Helyn Clack
Helyn Clack Deputy Cabinet Member for Children, Families and Lifelong Learning • Conservative
Profile image for Stephen Cooksey
Stephen Cooksey Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Clare Curran
Clare Curran Deputy Cabinet Member for Children, Families and Lifelong Learning • Conservative
Profile image for Nick Darby
Nick Darby Dittons and Weston Green Residents
Profile image for Fiona Davidson
Fiona Davidson  Residents for Guildford and Villages
Profile image for Paul Deach
Paul Deach Deputy Cabinet Member to the Leader of the Council • Conservative
Profile image for Kevin Deanus
Kevin Deanus Cabinet Member for Fire and Rescue, and Resilience • Conservative
Profile image for Jonathan Essex
Jonathan Essex The Green Party Group Leader • The Green Party
Profile image for Robert Evans OBE
Robert Evans OBE Labour & Labour Co-operative Group Leader • Labour
Profile image for Chris Farr
Chris Farr Independent
Profile image for Paul Follows
Paul Follows Liberal Democrats Group Leader and Leader of the Official Opposition • Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Will Forster
Will Forster  Liberal Democrats
Profile image for John Furey
John Furey  Conservative
Profile image for Matt Furniss
Matt Furniss Cabinet Member for Highways, Transport and Economic Growth • Conservative
Profile image for Angela Goodwin
Angela Goodwin Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Jeffrey Gray
Jeffrey Gray  Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Tim Hall
Tim Hall Chair of the Council • Conservative
Profile image for David Harmer
David Harmer Conservative
Profile image for Edward Hawkins
Edward Hawkins Conservative
Profile image for Marisa Heath
Marisa Heath Cabinet Member for Environment and Planning • Conservative
Profile image for Trefor Hogg
Trefor Hogg Conservative
Profile image for Robert Hughes
Robert Hughes Conservative
Profile image for Jonathan Hulley
Jonathan Hulley Cabinet Member for Children, Families and Lifelong Learning • Conservative
Profile image for Saj Hussain
Saj Hussain Conservative
Profile image for Frank Kelly
Frank Kelly Conservative
Profile image for Riasat Khan
Riasat Khan Independent
Profile image for Robert King
Robert King Labour and Co-operative
Profile image for Eber Kington
Eber Kington Residents Association
Profile image for David Lewis
David Lewis  Conservative
Profile image for David Lewis
David Lewis Cabinet Member for Finance and Resources • Conservative
Profile image for Scott Lewis
Scott Lewis Conservative
Profile image for Andy Lynch
Andy Lynch Reform UK Group Leader • Reform UK
Profile image for Andy MacLeod
Andy MacLeod Farnham Residents
Profile image for Ernest Mallett MBE
Ernest Mallett MBE Residents' Association and Independent
Profile image for Michaela Martin
Michaela Martin Farnham Residents
Profile image for Jan Mason
Jan Mason Residents Association
Profile image for Steven McCormick
Steven McCormick Residents Association
Profile image for Julia McShane
Julia McShane Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Sinead Mooney
Sinead Mooney Cabinet Member for Adult Social Care • Conservative
Profile image for Carla Morson
Carla Morson Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Bernie Muir
Bernie Muir Vice-Chair of the Council • Conservative
Profile image for Mark Nuti
Mark Nuti Cabinet Member for Health and Wellbeing, and Public Health • Conservative
Profile image for John O'Reilly
John O'Reilly Conservative
Profile image for Rebecca Paul
Rebecca Paul Conservative
Profile image for George Potter
George Potter Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Catherine Powell
Catherine Powell Residents' Association and Independent Group Leader • Farnham Residents
Profile image for Penny Rivers
Penny Rivers Liberal Democrats
Profile image for John Robini
John Robini Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Becky Rush
Becky Rush Conservative
Profile image for Joanne Sexton
Joanne Sexton Independent
Profile image for Lance Spencer
Lance Spencer Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Lesley Steeds
Lesley Steeds Conservative
Profile image for Mark Sugden
Mark Sugden  Conservative
Profile image for Richard Tear
Richard Tear Conservative
Profile image for Ashley Tilling
Ashley Tilling Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Chris Townsend
Chris Townsend Ashtead Independent, working with Ashtead Residents
Profile image for Liz Townsend
Liz Townsend Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Denise Turner-Stewart
Denise Turner-Stewart Deputy Leader and Cabinet Member for Customer and Communities • Conservative
Profile image for Hazel Watson
Hazel Watson Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Jeremy Webster
Jeremy Webster Conservative
Profile image for Fiona White
Fiona White Liberal Democrats
Profile image for Keith Witham
Keith Witham Conservative
Profile image for Liz Bowes
Liz Bowes Conservative
Profile image for Tim Oliver OBE
Tim Oliver OBE Leader of the Council • Conservative
Profile image for Matt Furniss
Matt Furniss Cabinet Member for Highways, Transport and Economic Growth • Conservative

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet Tuesday 10-Dec-2024 10.00 Council
Supplementary Agenda - Item 13 Tuesday 10-Dec-2024 10.00 Council

Reports Pack

Public reports pack Tuesday 10-Dec-2024 10.00 Council

Additional Documents

Item 7 - SCC - Electoral Review Final Report
Item 6 - Approval of County Councillor Absence
Item 8 - Appointment of Independent Persons
Item 14 - Cabinet 29 October 2024 - Minutes
Item 12 - Report of the Cabinet
Item 2 - Council 8 October 2024 - Minutes Merge
Item 2 - Appendix A - Item 5 - Leaders Statement - Council 8 October 2024
Item 13 - Cabinet 26 November 2024 - Draft Minutes
Supplementary Agenda - Items 9 and 11 Tuesday 10-Dec-2024 10.00 Council
Item 9 2 - Cabinet and Deputy Cabinet Member Briefings - 10 Dec 2024
Item 9 1 - Council Member Questions and Responses - 10 December 2024