Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Isles of Scilly Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

FULL COUNCIL - Wednesday, 25th June, 2025 6.00 pm

June 25, 2025 View on council website

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Will housing allocation policy changes face opposition?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

Here is a summary of the items scheduled for discussion at the Isles of Scilly Full Council meeting on 25 June 2025, according to the agenda and reports pack.

The meeting's agenda included planning matters, governance, financial performance, and policy reviews, with a focus on housing and infrastructure.

Items for Decision

Planning Application: Watch House, Tresco

Councillors were scheduled to look at a planning application for Watch House, Raven's Lane, Old Grimsby, Tresco. The application, P/25/020/HH, requests permission to replace an existing single-storey conservatory, add a new internal wall, demolish a small area of an existing internal wall, and add a small lean-to utility room.

The report in the report pack notes that the Lead Local Flood Authority responded to the application, confirming that the proposal is acceptable from a flooding perspective.

The planning officer's report recommends that the council approve the application, subject to conditions, and delegate authority to the Chief Planning Officer to make any minor changes required to the conditions.

Draft Annual Governance Statement 2024-25

The council was scheduled to consider its draft Annual Governance Statement (AGS) for 2024-25. The Draft AGS Report sets out the key elements of the council's governance and internal control features, measuring its compliance with its local Code of Governance and the CIPFA/SOLACE Framework. Any significant governance issues identified during the year are to be set out in the AGS, along with descriptions of action already taken and any planned action to be taken during 2025-26.

The Governance Committee considered the draft AGS at its meeting on 17 June 2025 and agreed to recommend it to the Full Council for approval in draft form.

4th Quarter 2024/25 Financial Performance Report

The council was scheduled to discuss its financial performance in the 4th quarter of 2024/25. The 4th Quarter Financial Performance Report includes the revenue budget outturn by service, savings delivery, capital programme outturn, council tax and business rates collection performance, and treasury management updates.

The report notes an overspend of £985,673, which is 14% of the net budget. The main drivers for the overspend are Children Services and Adult Services. The report also details how the overspend will be funded, including transfers from specific reserves and the general fund reserve.

The report recommends that members note the financial performance and approve the reserve transfers.

Council Performance Summary and Corporate Risk Register

Councillors were scheduled to review the council's performance summary for the fourth quarter of 2024/25, along with the corporate risk register. The Report Q4 Performance and Risk includes a performance summary (Appendix A), methodologies (Appendix B), and the corporate risk register (Appendix C).

Housing Allocations Policy Review

The council was scheduled to discuss a review of its Housing Allocations Policy. The Report Housing Allocations Policy review presents the findings of a public consultation on proposed changes to the policy, with a summary of the responses included in Appendix G.

The report sets out proposed changes to the eligibility criteria and prioritisation of applicants, and asks members to confirm whether any additional preference should be added to the policy, adopt the revised policy, and agree to monitor the policy's outcomes with an annual review.

Complaint Handling Failure Notice - Housing Ombudsman

The council was scheduled to note the contents of a Complaint Handling Failure Notice from the Housing Ombudsman1. The Complaint Handling Failure Notice Housing Ombudsman relates to a procedural delay in providing a complete annual submission to the Ombudsman, and does not relate to a failure to deal with an individual customer.

The report summarises the circumstances of the failure, and sets out lessons learned.

Providing Feedback Policy Update

The council was scheduled to consider further changes to the council's complaints policy, now called the Providing Feedback Policy. The Providing Feedback Policy Update June 2025 presents the updated policy, incorporating changes approved on 29 May 2025, and further revisions to reflect current council roles and service structures.

Highway Maintenance Manual and Asset Management Policy

The council was scheduled to discuss and approve the Highway Maintenance Manual and Asset Management Policy. The Highway Maintenance Manual and Asset Management Policy Report includes the Highway Maintenance Manual (Appendix A) and the Highway Asset Management Policy (Appendix B).

The Highway Maintenance Manual documents the council's approach to highway maintenance, while the Asset Management Policy outlines the principles and practices for managing the council's highway assets.

Other Matters

Minutes from Committees

The council was scheduled to receive draft minutes from the Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 10 June 2025, and the Governance Committee held on 17 June 2025.


  1. The Housing Ombudsman is a free, impartial and independent service that resolves disputes between tenants and landlords who are registered with them. 

Attendees

Profile image for CouncillorJohn Peacock
Councillor John Peacock  Lead Member for Environment, Environmental Services and Climate Change •  Independent
Profile image for CouncillorTim Dean
Councillor Tim Dean Lead Member for Housing & Corporate Estate, and Chairman of Licensing Committee • Independent
Profile image for CouncillorRobert Francis
Councillor Robert Francis CHAIRMAN OF COUNCIL • Independent
Profile image for CouncillorHarry Legg
Councillor Harry Legg  Councillor for St Agnes •  Independent
Profile image for CouncillorDan Marcus
Councillor Dan Marcus  Lead Member for Planning & Regulatory Services and Chairman of Governance Committee •  Independent
Profile image for CouncillorEuan Rodger
Councillor Euan Rodger  Isles of Scilly Member of Devon & Cornwall Police and Crime Panel •  Independent
Profile image for CouncillorJoel Williams
Councillor Joel Williams  Vice-Chairman of Council and Lead Member for Children •  Independent
Profile image for CouncillorRobert Dorrien-Smith
Councillor Robert Dorrien-Smith Councillor for Tresco • Independent
Profile image for CouncillorMrs Fran Grottick
Councillor Mrs Fran Grottick Councillor for St Marys • Independent
Profile image for CouncillorAndrew Guy
Councillor Andrew Guy Councillor for St Mary's and Chairman of the IFCA • Independent
Profile image for CouncillorMrs Avril Mumford
Councillor Mrs Avril Mumford  Lead Member for Adults & Public Health and Chairman of the Scrutiny Committee •  Independent
Profile image for CouncillorSteve Sims
Councillor Steve Sims  Lead Member for Economy, Tourism & Transport •  Independent
Councillor Lynn Blackwell Councillor for St Mary's + Vice-Chairman of Scrutiny Committee • Independent
Profile image for CouncillorStuart Nixon
Councillor Stuart Nixon  Lead member for Finance, Governance, Risk and Performance and Corporate Services •  Independent
Profile image for CouncillorAlex Sandford
Councillor Alex Sandford  Councillor for Bryher •  Independent

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 25th-Jun-2025 18.00 FULL COUNCIL.pdf

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 25th-Jun-2025 18.00 FULL COUNCIL.pdf

Additional Documents

Draft AGS Report.pdf
APPENDIX A - Council of the Isles of Scilly Highway Maintenance Manual inc Winter Plan.pdf
APPENDIX B - Council of the Isles of Scilly Highway Asset Management.pdf
APPENDIX C - Highway Code of Practice Summary of Recommendations.pdf
PART 2 SHEET.pdf
APPENDIX D - Highway Condition Survey Summary Report.pdf
cover for draft reports to council.pdf
Complaint Handling Failure Notice Housing Ombudsman.pdf
Appendix E- Housing Prioritisation Assessment Consultation draft.pdf
Appendix A Complaint Handling Failure Notice.pdf
CIOS 4th Quarter 24-25 Finance report to members 16.06.25.pdf
Appendix B - performance measures - methodologies.pdf
Appendix C - WORKING DOCUMENT PLEASE USE Corporate Risk Register.pdf
Report Housing Allocations Policy review.pdf
Appendix B Housing Register Allocation Policy Consultation draft.pdf
Appendix A - Housing Allocations Policy existing.pdf
APPENDIX D Housing Allocation Point System Existing.pdf
Appendix C- Housing Allocations Policy.pdf
P-25-020 Committee Report.pdf
AGS 2024-25.pdf
Report Q4 Performance and Risk.pdf
Appendix A - Q4 202425 performance.pdf
Providing Feedback Policy Update June 2025.pdf
APPENDIX A UsingFeedbackFinal 2017.pdf
APPENDIX B Feedback Policy June 2025.pdf
Highway Maintenance Manual and Asset Management Policy Report.pdf
Minutes 20052025 FULL COUNCIL.pdf
Minutes 29052025 FULL COUNCIL.pdf
Minutes 17062025 Governance Committee.pdf
Minutes 10062025 Scrutiny Committee.pdf