Subscribe to updates

You'll receive weekly summaries about Isles of Scilly Council every week.

If you have any requests or comments please let us know at community@opencouncil.network. We can also provide custom updates on particular topics across councils.

FULL COUNCIL - Tuesday, 16th December, 2025 10.30 am

December 16, 2025 View on council website

Chat with this meeting

Subscribe to our professional plan to ask questions about this meeting.

“Will the council debate specific budget allocations?”

Subscribe to chat
AI Generated

Summary

The Full Council of the Isles of Scilly is scheduled to meet on 16 December 2025 to discuss financial performance, council performance, land disposal, biodiversity, climate adaptation, civil enforcement, post-16 funding, and housing for homeless young people.

Financial Performance

The council is scheduled to review the 2nd Quarter 2025/26 - Financial Performance Report. The report highlights the revenue budget monitoring by service, savings risk monitoring, capital programme monitoring, major project monitoring, council tax collection performance, business rates collection performance, water rates collection performance, housing rent collection performance, sundry debt position, payment performance and a treasury management update. The report indicates a forecast overspend of £849,186, which is an increase from Quarter 1. A significant portion of this overspend is attributed to pressures within Adult Services, with agency staffing costs likely to exceed £700,000 for the year. The report recommends that the council initiate an action plan to reduce net expenditure on Adult Social Care, review housing rent collection performance, and address issues causing poor rental collection levels. The report also includes an update on the Culture Centre and Museum Project, noting programme slippage with a revised planned completion date of 30 June 2026, though the contractual date remains 25 June 2026.

Council Performance and Risk

The council is scheduled to discuss the Council performance summary and corporate risk register: quarter 2 2025/26. The performance summary includes updates to the tables since Quarter 1, with each risk now including a line for current year actual performance, the target for the year, and last year's actuals. The report notes that further work is needed on agreeing the methodology for calculating some of the targets, and that work is still required around the children service indicators. The corporate risk register includes narrative relating to each risk, completed by the identified owner of that risk. An additional column has been added to link the risks to the Council's Corporate Plan. The register identifies several risks, including:

  • Ofsted rating of Isles of Scilly Children's Services
  • Insufficient affordable housing for local permanent residents
  • Failure to deliver an integrated health and social care system
  • Inability to recruit and retain staff
  • Failure to meet carbon neutral ambition by 2030
  • Inability to maintain financial sustainability
  • Cyber-attack
  • Ineffective business continuity planning arrangements
  • Insufficient capacity and expertise to deliver on commitments to capital projects
  • Failure to establish adequate competence and co-operation for civil protection and emergency planning duties
  • Transport links to the Isles of Scilly becoming unaffordable and unreliable
  • Failure to meet regulatory requirements for the council's corporate estate
  • Failure to create the right organisational conditions and culture to work together effectively and efficiently
  • Cornwall Council becoming less willing and able to provide support contained within the collaboration agreements

Biodiversity Reporting Duty

The council is scheduled to discuss the Biodiversity Reporting Duty report. The report sets out how the Council of the Isles of Scilly has met its statutory obligations during the reporting period and outlines future actions to embed biodiversity across council functions. The report notes that the Isles of Scilly benefits from extensive natural designations, including Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI)1, Special Protection Areas (SPA)2, and Special Area of Conservation (SAC)3, covering over 80% of the land area. The report details measures taken, including integration of biodiversity into planning policy, adoption of digital tools, and partnership work through the Joint Local Nature Recovery Strategy. During the reporting period, 6 planning applications triggered the statutory Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG) duty, and officers have considered one application to deliver an on-island Habitat Bank. Once implemented, these applications and habitat bank combined, have the potential to deliver 8.7 hectares of new area-habitat and 2.7 hectares of hedgerow-habitat. Planned actions include developing local BNG guidance and confirming the first habitat bank, embedding Local Nature Recovery Strategy (LNRS) priorities into the Local Plan review, and commissioning a Landscape Character and Recreational Pressure Assessment.

Proposed Disposal of Land at Porthcressa

The council is scheduled to discuss the Proposed disposal of land at Porthcressa report. The report relates to the proposed disposal of land at Porthcressa to National Grid to enable the development of a new electrical substation to serve the Town Hall redevelopment and improve supply resilience in Hugh Town. The works will require the partial removal of the embankment created as part of the Porthcressa regeneration works. The land transfer will be for a nominal cost of £1, and the council will be expected to pay the legal fees in relation to the transfer as part of the Capital costs for the Town Hall redevelopment.

Other Matters

The agenda for the meeting also includes the following items:

  • Climate Adaptation Scilly - Phase 2
  • Civil Enforcement and On Street Parking
  • Post 16 - Residue Funding and an Open Letter to DFE
  • Housing Protocol for homeless Young People
  • Declarations of Interest
  • Minutes of Previous Meeting
  • Chairman's Announcements
  • Consideration of any questions received under Standing Order 14
  • Consideration of any Motions received in accordance with Standing Order 12
  • To receive draft minutes from committees for information only
  • Urgent Items

  1. Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSIs) are areas designated by Natural England as being of special interest under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 (as amended). 

  2. Special Protection Areas (SPAs) are strictly protected sites classified in accordance with Article 4 of the EC Directive on the conservation of wild birds (79/409/EEC) (the 'Birds Directive') for rare and vulnerable birds and for regularly occurring migratory species. 

  3. Special Areas of Conservation (SACs) are protected sites designated under the European Union's Habitats Directive. 

Attendees

Profile image for Councillor John Peacock
Councillor John Peacock Lead Member for Environment, Environmental Services and Climate Change • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Tim Dean
Councillor Tim Dean Lead Member for Housing & Corporate Estate, and Chairman of Licensing Committee • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Robert Francis
Councillor Robert Francis CHAIRMAN OF COUNCIL • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Harry Legg
Councillor Harry Legg Councillor for St Agnes • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Dan Marcus
Councillor Dan Marcus Lead Member for Planning & Regulatory Services and Chairman of Governance Committee • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Euan Rodger
Councillor Euan Rodger Isles of Scilly Member of Devon & Cornwall Police and Crime Panel • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Joel Williams
Councillor Joel Williams Vice-Chairman of Council and Lead Member for Children • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Robert Dorrien-Smith
Councillor Robert Dorrien-Smith Councillor for Tresco • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Mrs Fran Grottick
Councillor Mrs Fran Grottick Councillor for St Marys • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Andrew Guy
Councillor Andrew Guy Councillor for St Mary's and Chairman of the IFCA • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Mrs Avril Mumford
Councillor Mrs Avril Mumford Lead Member for Adults & Public Health and Chairman of the Scrutiny Committee • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Steve Sims
Councillor Steve Sims Lead Member for Economy, Tourism & Transport • Independent
Councillor Lynn Blackwell Councillor for St Mary's + Vice-Chairman of Scrutiny Committee • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Stuart Nixon
Councillor Stuart Nixon Lead member for Finance, Governance, Risk and Performance and Corporate Services • Independent
Profile image for Councillor Alex Sandford
Councillor Alex Sandford Councillor for Bryher • Independent

Topics

No topics have been identified for this meeting yet.

Meeting Documents

Agenda

Agenda frontsheet 16th-Dec-2025 10.30 FULL COUNCIL.pdf

Reports Pack

Public reports pack 16th-Dec-2025 10.30 FULL COUNCIL.pdf

Additional Documents

Minutes 18112025 FULL COUNCIL.pdf
Minutes 20102025 Isles of Scilly Inshore Fisheries Conservation Authority IFCA.pdf
Minutes 13102025 Health and Wellbeing Board.pdf
cover for draft reports to council.pdf
2nd Quarter 25-26 Finance report v1.pdf
Report Q2 Performance and Risk.pdf
Appendix A Council performance summary Q2 2025.pdf
Appendix B - Corporate Risk Register.pdf
Biodiversity Reporting Duty Committee Report.pdf
Appendix A Biodiversity Duty Report.pdf
PART 2 SHEET.pdf
Proposed disposal of land at Porthcressa.pdf
Appendix B BNG from Planning.pdf
SUPPLEMENT PACK A - 3 items 16th-Dec-2025 10.30 FULL COUNCIL.pdf
Climate Adapdation Scilly - Phase 2.pdf
Appendix A - Scrutiny Committee Report - Climate Adaptaton Scilly - Phase 1.pdf
Civil Enforcement and On Street Parking.pdf
Draft Cover report for YP homeless protocol.pdf
Joint-protocol-assessing-and-supporting-homeless-young-people-aged-16-and-17 Updated PC.pdf
SUPPLEMENT PACK B - 1 item 16th-Dec-2025 10.30 FULL COUNCIL.pdf
Draft Report- Post 16 16Dec2025.pdf